为什么长者不应像年轻人那样运动：一位有 40 年经验医生的忠告Why Older People Shouldn't Exercise as Much as Young People

 

为什么长者不应像年轻人那样运动：一位有 40 年经验医生的忠告

最近我看到一段很值得思考的视频，是一位有 40 年临床经验的中国骨科与老年科医生的讲解。他的提醒让我印象深刻：长者不能像年轻人那样运动，否则可能得到伤害而不是好处。

医生解释说，随着年龄增长，我们的身体器官和功能都会逐渐退化：心脏和血管弹性下降，骨骼变得脆弱，关节和软骨磨损，大脑和感觉系统反应变慢。这些都是自然老化的现象，也意味着我们的身体已经无法再承受年轻人习惯的高强度运动。

重点是：如果长者模仿年轻人的运动方式——例如剧烈跑步、大重量训练或高强度的耐力运动，身体根本无法承受。 不仅得不到锻炼的效果，反而可能伤害心脏、关节，甚至留下长期隐患。

我自己也常看到一些热心的朋友，在公园里拼命跑步，或者坚持做很吃力的力量训练，觉得这样才是“保持年轻”。其实，医生提醒我们，这样的方式反而可能让身体受伤。对长者来说，运动应该是 温和、规律、适合身体情况的，而不是一味追求强度。

那么，长者该选择什么样的运动呢？医生和我的观察都指出：

• 低冲击运动：如散步、游泳、太极或骑自行车。

• 柔韧和平衡训练：减少跌倒风险。

• 轻量力量训练：增强肌肉，但要注意循序渐进。

• 适度的有氧活动：让心脏保持活力，但避免过度负荷。

不过，陈医生并不仅仅提醒我们要避免风险，他也提出了非常实用的解决方案。他强烈推荐长者尝试床上和椅子上的运动，这些运动安全性高，而且效果非常好。

例如：

• 在床上做轻柔的抬腿或伸展动作。

• 坐在椅子上做手臂环绕、轻度阻力锻炼或原地踏步。

• 躺在床上进行深呼吸配合伸展的放松运动。

这些看似简单的运动，实际上能有效促进血液循环、保持关节灵活、维持一定的肌肉力量。运动并不需要激烈才能有效，对长者来说，安全与持续才是关键。

其中的智慧其实很简单：运动就像药，剂量合适才有效。

对朋友和读者们来说，保持活动是任何年龄段都需要的，但方式必须随着年龄调整。我们追求的不是和年轻人比较，而是维持灵活、独立和有品质的生活。

Hashtags

#健康老化 #长者运动 #运动保健 #老年关怀 #骨科健康 #长寿之道

---

Why Older People Shouldn't Exercise as Much as Young People

This morning I came across a thought-provoking video narrated by a Chinese doctor who has devoted more than 40 years to orthopedics and geriatric care. His words struck me deeply, especially since many of us are trying to stay active and healthy as we age. But his message was clear: not all exercises are suitable for seniors, and doing the wrong kind can cause more harm than good.

The doctor explained that as we grow older, our internal organs and physical structures no longer function at their youthful capacity. The heart and blood vessels lose flexibility, bones become more brittle, joints and cartilage wear down, and our brains and sensory systems respond more slowly. These are natural changes of aging, but they mean that we cannot push our bodies the same way younger people do.

Here’s the key takeaway: if seniors exercise with the same intensity or style as young adults—high-impact, high-resistance, or overly strenuous routines—the body simply cannot cope. Instead of gaining the benefits of exercise, seniors may face injuries, exhaustion, or long-term harm to their vital organs and skeletal system.

It reminded me of the many well-meaning older friends I see in the park, running or doing heavy strength training, thinking they are “keeping young.” In reality, the doctor reminds us, such practices can backfire. For seniors, exercise should be gentle, consistent, and supportive of overall function rather than extreme or competitive.

So what should seniors focus on instead? The doctor and my own observations point to:

• Low-impact activities like walking, swimming, tai chi, or cycling.

• Flexibility and balance training to prevent falls.

• Light strength training for muscle support, but done with care.

• Moderate cardiovascular activity that keeps the heart engaged without overstraining.

But he didn’t just issue a warning — he also gave us hope and guidance. Dr. Chan highly recommends safe and effective alternatives, such as exercises that can be done in bed or while sitting on a chair. These movements are much safer for seniors because they minimize strain, yet they are surprisingly effective in maintaining flexibility, improving circulation, and preserving muscle strength.

Some examples include:

• Gentle leg raises or stretches while lying in bed.

• Arm circles, light resistance exercises, or seated marching while sitting in a chair.

• Controlled breathing and stretching routines that can be done without leaving the bed.

These simple yet powerful routines prove that exercise doesn’t need to be extreme to be effective. For seniors, the goal is not to “push limits” but to stay mobile, safe, and independent.

The wisdom here is simple but profound: exercise is medicine, but only if it is taken in the right dose.

For friends and readers in our community, let’s remember that staying active is vital at every age, but the way we move should match the stage of life we are in. Our goal is not to compete with youth, but to preserve mobility, independence, and quality of life for the years ahead.

---

Hashtags

#HealthyAging #SeniorFitness #ExerciseWisely #GeriatricCare #HealthyLifestyle #Orthopedics #Longevity

膝蓋就是這樣壞掉的！復健科醫師提醒：這5個壞習慣一定要戒掉，別等走不動才後悔！